Skip to content
Malloy Industries

Post-Rejection Follow-Up Templates

Template 5 min to complete Fill it in here, then print or save it

A "no" from an investor is rarely a "never." It is usually "not yet," "not enough proof," or "wrong timing." The CEOs who eventually close those investors are the ones who handled the rejection well and stayed in touch. These three templates turn a no into a relationship that can convert later. Send them, then keep your word and follow through.

Template 1: Immediate Response to a Rejection

Send within 24 hours of the no.

Subject: Re: [original subject] – thank you

Hi [Investor first name],

Thank you for the straight answer and for taking the time. I would rather hear a clear no than be left guessing.

If you are open to it, I would value one thing: what was the main reason this was not a fit right now? Was it stage, traction, market, or something about the team? Honest feedback helps me more than you know, and I will not argue with it.

Either way, I would like to keep you posted on our progress. The next time we talk, I want the numbers to make this an easy decision.

Thanks again,

[Your name]

Customization notes: Ask for the real reason in a way that is easy to answer (give them the menu: stage, traction, market, team). Do not push back on the no. The goal is information and an open door, not a re-pitch.

Template 2: The 90-Day Follow-Up

Send roughly three months later, when you have real progress to show.

Subject: [Company] – 90 days later

Hi [Investor first name],

When we spoke in [month], you passed because [the reason they gave]. I took that seriously. Here is where we are now:

  • Progress point 1 – ideally addressing their exact objection.
  • Progress point 2
  • Progress point 3

I just wanted to keep my word and keep you in the loop. If anything here changes the picture for you, I would be glad to reconnect.

[Your name]

Customization notes: Lead with their original objection and then show progress against it. Make clear there is no ask. This builds trust and keeps you top of mind without being needy.

Template 3: The Milestone Update

Send when you hit a number that directly answers why they passed.

Subject: [Company] – we just hit [milestone]

Hi [Investor first name],

Last time, the thing holding you back was [their objection]. I wanted you to be among the first to know: we just [the milestone that addresses it – a revenue number, a major customer, a growth rate].

If that changes things, I would love to find 20 minutes. We are opening the next round / making room for a few more investors, and I would rather work with people who know our story.

[Calendar link]

[Your name]

Customization notes: This is the one with an ask, and you have earned it because the milestone removes their reason for passing. Keep it short and confident. The momentum is the pitch.

A Note on Handling Rejection Well

Every no is data. Log the reason in your Investor Pipeline Tracker. When you see the same objection three times, the market is telling you what to fix before you raise again. Treat the people who passed as a warm list, not a closed door.

Your next step

Turn an investor 'no' into a future yes. This template comes from 'Turn Investor Rejections into Gold'. Read the article for the thinking behind it.

Part of: Turn Investor Rejections into Gold